How AI Is Revolutionizing Fact-Checking and Fraud Prevention
By Cap Puckhaber, MarketingSpiritual.com, Reno, Nevada
Updated: 10/31/26
AI tools can draft a blog post, summarize a report or answer a customer’s question in seconds. They can also invent a statistic, misquote a source or cite a study that doesn’t exist, all with the same confident tone. For marketers, that combination is risky. Speed is useful, but publishing something false can undo years of trust in a single post.
This post covers both sides of AI and accuracy. I’ll share real cases where AI errors cost businesses money and credibility. Then I’ll explain what AI can and can’t do when it comes to checking facts, and walk through the process I use to keep AI-assisted content accurate. If you use AI in your marketing at all, fact-checking is the habit that protects everything else you do.
Why fact-checking matters more with AI
AI is often confidently wrong
Everyone makes mistakes, including people. What makes AI errors dangerous is the complete confidence behind them. A wrong answer delivered in a calm, authoritative tone is easy to miss.
A study from Columbia University’s Tow Center for Digital Journalism shows how big the problem can be. Nieman Lab reported that AI search engines failed to produce accurate citations in more than 60% of tests. Researchers gave eight AI search tools quotes from real news articles and asked them to identify the source. Across 1,600 queries, the tools usually got it wrong.
The results varied widely. Perplexity had the lowest failure rate at 37%, while Grok-3 Search failed 94% of the time. ChatGPT gave 134 incorrect citations, and only 15 of those included any hedging language. In other words, the tool rarely signaled when it wasn’t sure.
That’s the core lesson for marketers. A confident answer from an AI tool tells you nothing about whether it’s correct. Confidence is a writing style, and accuracy is something you have to check.
The Deloitte report
Even large, sophisticated firms have been caught out. Fortune reported that Deloitte agreed to partially refund the Australian government over a report that contained AI-generated errors. The 237-page report on a welfare compliance framework cost about $290,000.
A University of Sydney researcher found references to academic papers that didn’t exist. The report also included a fabricated quote attributed to a federal court judgment and a book attributed to a professor who never wrote it. Deloitte later published a revised version that disclosed it had used Azure OpenAI and removed the false references.
Deloitte said the corrections didn’t affect the report’s findings. But the damage to credibility was done. The story spread worldwide, and the firm’s name became attached to a cautionary tale about AI. A careful fact-check before publishing would have cost far less than the refund and the headlines.
The case also shows how errors get found. An outside reader with expertise in the subject spotted the fake references. Your readers include experts too, and some of them will check your sources. Assuming nobody will notice is a gamble that rarely pays off.
The Air Canada chatbot
AI errors can also create legal liability. CBC News reported on a case where Air Canada was found liable for its chatbot’s bad advice. A passenger named Jake Moffatt asked the airline’s chatbot about bereavement fares after a death in his family. The chatbot told him he could apply for a reduced fare within 90 days of buying a full-price ticket.
That wasn’t the airline’s actual policy. When Moffatt applied, Air Canada refused, and it argued the chatbot was a separate legal entity responsible for its own actions. The tribunal called that “a remarkable submission.” It found that Air Canada hadn’t taken reasonable care to make sure its chatbot was accurate and ordered the airline to pay the difference.
The amount was small, at $812. But the lesson was big. If your AI tool tells customers something, your business owns that statement. Courts and customers alike will hold you to it.
What’s at stake for a small business
A large firm can survive an embarrassing AI error. Small businesses often have less room. One false claim in a blog post or ad can lose a customer who catches it, and that customer may tell others. Small businesses run on reputation, so accuracy matters even more for them.
Legal risk scales down too. A false product claim, a made-up testimonial or a wrong policy statement from a chatbot can all create problems. The amounts may be smaller than in big cases, but they can hurt a small budget badly.
There’s an upside, though. Because many businesses now publish AI content without checking it, accurate content stands out. Readers notice when a business gets the details right, and that becomes part of why they trust you.
Can AI fact-check itself
What AI does well
AI can be a helpful part of a fact-checking process, as long as a person stays in charge. It’s good at scanning a long draft and listing every factual claim, number and name that needs checking. That alone saves time, because it’s easy to miss a claim buried in the middle of a paragraph. On a long report, that list can run to dozens of items.
Some AI tools with web search can also help locate possible sources for a claim. They can summarize long reports so you know which section to read closely. Some can also flag inconsistencies, like a number that appears differently in two places in the same draft.
Used this way, AI works like a research assistant. It points you toward what to check and where to look. The actual checking still has to happen against real sources.
A prompt I find useful is asking the tool to list every claim in a draft that a skeptical reader might question. The list is rarely complete, but it often catches claims I would have skimmed past. Then I check each one myself.
Where AI falls short
Asking an AI tool whether its own answer is correct doesn’t reliably work. The same patterns that produced an error can produce a confident confirmation of that error. Some tools will even invent a source to back up a claim they made up.
AI also struggles with recent information. Most models have a knowledge cutoff, and even tools with web search can mix old and new details. Prices, policies, laws and platform rules change often, so an AI answer about any of them can be out of date without warning.
Context is another weak spot. AI might quote a statistic accurately while missing that it came from a tiny sample or a biased survey. A person reading the original source catches those details far more often.
AI can also miss what a source leaves out. A report might include an important caveat on page 40 that changes how a headline number should be read. Summaries tend to drop those caveats, so reading the original matters even more when the stakes are high.
Using AI search tools wisely
AI tools with web search can be more useful for fact-checking than tools without it. They can pull up recent pages and show links you can click. That makes them a reasonable starting point when you’re hunting for a source.
Still, the Tow Center results show these tools often cite the wrong page or invent a link. So treat every link they give you as a lead to follow up. Open it, read it and make sure it says what the tool claimed. If the tool can’t produce a working link to a real source, assume the claim is unverified.
My fact-checking process for AI-assisted content
Highlight every claim
Before I publish anything that AI helped create, I go through the draft and highlight every factual claim. That includes numbers, dates, names, quotes, product details and any statement about what a study or law says. If a sentence could be proven true or false, it gets highlighted.
This step sounds tedious, and it is. But it forces me to see exactly how many claims a draft contains. AI drafts often include more specific claims than I expected, many of them added without being asked. Seeing them all highlighted makes it obvious how much checking a draft really needs.
Go to the original source
For each highlighted claim, I find the original source. That means the actual study, report, press release, court ruling or company page, rather than a blog post that mentions it. Secondary sources often repeat errors or strip away important context.
If I can’t find the original within a few minutes, the claim gets cut or rewritten without the specific detail. “Most consumers say transparency matters” can stand in for a percentage I can’t verify. It’s less precise, but it’s honest. Readers rarely miss a number that was never there, and they never forgive one that was made up.
When I do find the source, I read the relevant section myself. I check that the number matches, that the sample and date make sense and that the claim reflects what the source actually said. It’s surprising how often a real number turns out to describe something slightly different from the claim built on it.
Click every link
AI tools sometimes produce links that look real but lead nowhere. The Tow Center study found that some AI search engines pointed users to error pages over and over. A broken link makes your content look careless, and a link to the wrong page can mislead readers.
So I click every link before publishing. I make sure it loads, goes to the right page and actually supports the claim it’s attached to. It takes a few minutes and catches problems surprisingly often. I also recheck links on older posts every so often, since pages move and sites shut down over time.
Check dates and freshness
Even accurate facts can be misleading if they’re old. A statistic from several years ago might no longer reflect reality. Platform policies might have changed since the AI learned about it.
I note the date of every source I use. If a number is more than a couple of years old, I either look for newer data or mention its age in the content. For anything involving prices, laws or platform rules, I confirm the current version on the day I publish. Those details change often enough that a source from last year may already be wrong.
Verify quotes and attributions
Quotes deserve extra care. AI tools sometimes invent quotes or attach real quotes to the wrong person. The Deloitte case included exactly this kind of error, with a fabricated quote attributed to a court.
Every quote I publish has to come from a source I can link to or name. If I can’t confirm who said something and where, the quote comes out. Paraphrasing a verified idea is always safer than publishing an unverified quote. Readers who check a fake quote and find nothing will doubt everything else you wrote.
Watch for statistics without context
Some AI errors are subtle. A statistic might be real but stripped of the context that makes it meaningful. For example, a survey of 400 people gets presented as a fact about all consumers. Or a finding from one country gets applied everywhere.
When I check a number, I look at who was surveyed, how many people took part and when. If the sample is small or narrow, I say so in the content. That small addition makes the claim more honest and helps readers judge it for themselves.
Keep a simple source log
For longer pieces, I keep a quick list of every source I used, with the claim it supports and the date I checked it. This doesn’t need special software. A simple document works fine.
A source log makes updates much easier later. When a reader questions a claim, I can find the source in seconds. And when I refresh an old post, I know exactly which numbers to recheck.
A mistake I’ve learned to avoid
Here’s the “don’t” I’d underline. Don’t trust an AI citation just because it looks specific. Early on, I’d see a neat statistic attributed to a well-known research firm and assume it was probably right. When I started checking every one, I found numbers that didn’t appear anywhere in the cited source. Some came from different studies, and some didn’t seem to exist at all.
Specific details make a claim feel more credible, which is exactly why fabricated specifics are so dangerous. A precise percentage with a decimal point looks researched. Naming a study makes it sound authoritative. Neither tells you whether the claim is real.
Now I treat every AI-supplied citation as unverified until I’ve seen the source myself. That habit has saved me from publishing several errors that would have embarrassed me and misled readers. It also made me a better writer, because the real sources usually had more interesting details than the AI summary.
The cairn problem
Hikers sometimes stack small piles of rocks, called cairns, to mark a route across open terrain. A good cairn line can guide you safely across a confusing slope. But not every cairn is reliable. Some were built by people who were lost themselves, and following them can lead you off route.
Experienced hikers use cairns as hints and check them against a map. They don’t follow a line of rocks just because someone stacked them confidently. AI output deserves the same treatment. It can point you in a useful direction, but you still need to check it against something you trust before you commit.
The hikers who get into trouble are usually the ones who stopped checking. They followed the first few cairns carefully, got comfortable and then trusted the rest without looking. Fact-checking works best as a steady habit for the same reason.
Fact-checking AI images and video
Text isn’t the only thing that needs checking. AI image tools can produce product photos that don’t match the real product, or scenes that never happened. Using those images without care can mislead customers about what they’re buying.
If you use AI images in marketing, label them as AI-generated where they appear. Never use AI to create images that pass as real customers, real events or real product results. For product listings, use actual photos of the actual product.
Be careful with images and videos you didn’t create, too. Deepfakes and edited images spread quickly on social media. Before sharing anything dramatic or surprising, look for confirmation from a trusted news source or the original creator.
Fact-checking customer-facing AI
Chatbots and AI assistants that talk directly to customers need even more care than AI-drafted content. A blog post gets reviewed before it publishes. Chatbots answer in real time, with no one checking each response.
Start by limiting what a customer-facing AI can talk about. Give it accurate, current information about your policies, prices and products, and keep that information updated. Test it regularly by asking the questions customers actually ask, including tricky ones. Whenever a policy changes, update the chatbot the same day.
Make it easy for customers to reach a person, especially for anything involving money, refunds or important decisions. Review a sample of real chatbot conversations every month to spot wrong answers. Label the chatbot clearly as AI. The Air Canada case shows that a business is responsible for what its chatbot says, so treat its answers as if your own staff had said them.
Where AI helps fight fraud and misinformation
AI can also be a powerful tool for spotting problems at scale. Banks and payment companies use machine learning to flag unusual transactions, like purchases that don’t match a customer’s normal timing, location or spending. That kind of pattern detection catches fraud faster than people could on their own.
Platforms use similar tools to detect fake accounts, spam and coordinated misinformation campaigns. Fact-checking organizations use AI to monitor large volumes of social posts and surface claims worth investigating. In each case, AI handles the scanning, while people make the final judgment.
Those tools have limits too. Fraud detection systems produce false alarms, and deepfake detectors can miss well-made fakes. The best results come from combining AI’s speed with human review, which is the same approach I recommend for marketing content. For a small business, that might mean using your payment processor’s fraud alerts and reviewing any flagged orders yourself.
Correcting errors after you publish
Even with a careful process, mistakes sometimes slip through. When a reader points out an error, fix it quickly and say so. A short note at the bottom of a post explaining what changed is enough.
Avoid quietly editing a mistake away without acknowledgment, especially if people already shared the original. Owning the correction shows readers that accuracy matters to you. Most people respect a business that admits and fixes errors far more than one that pretends they never happened. Thank the reader who caught it, too, since they did you a favor.
Building a fact-checking habit into your team
If anyone on your team uses AI to create content, fact-checking should be a written rule. Make it clear that every published piece needs a human review of claims, sources, links and quotes. Put the person who publishes in charge of signing off on accuracy.
A simple checklist helps. Highlight claims, find original sources, click links, check dates and verify quotes. Keep it short enough that people actually use it. Over time, it becomes a normal part of the workflow. New team members pick it up quickly when they see everyone else following it.
Celebrate catches, too. When someone finds an error before it goes live, thank them. That signals that accuracy matters more than speed, which is the message you want everyone to absorb.
Leave time for checking in your schedule as well. Rushed deadlines are where most errors slip through. If a piece needs to publish today, start the fact-check early instead of squeezing it in at the last minute.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can AI tools fact-check their own answers?
AI tools can’t do this reliably. An AI tool can confidently confirm an error it made or invent a source to support it. Use AI to find claims and possible sources, then verify them yourself against original material.
How often do AI tools get citations wrong?
They get them wrong quite often. A Tow Center study found AI search engines failed to produce accurate citations in more than 60% of tests. Results varied by tool, but none were perfect.
Is my business responsible for what its chatbot says?
In general, your business is responsible. During a Canadian case, Air Canada was held liable after its chatbot gave a customer incorrect information about a fare policy. Treat chatbot answers as if your own staff said them.
What is the fastest way to fact-check AI content?
Highlight every factual claim, then check each one against its original source. Click every link and confirm quotes. Cut or rewrite anything you can’t verify quickly.
Should I stop using AI because of these risks?
You don’t need to stop using it. AI can save real time on drafting and research. What matters is keeping a person responsible for accuracy before anything is published.
Can AI help detect fraud and misinformation?
Yes, AI is widely used to flag unusual transactions, fake accounts and coordinated misinformation. It works best alongside human review, since it can produce false alarms and miss sophisticated fakes. People should make the final call on anything flagged.
Check out A Responsible Approach for Using AI in Marketing
New: New ChatGPT Model Raises Alarms: The Ethical Concerns for Marketers
Read Top 10 Deceptive Marketing Scams to Avoid
More Blogs from Cap Puckhaber

Follow Cap Puckhaber on Social Media
- Connect with Cap Puckhaber on Facebook
- See Cap Puckhaber’s latest adventures on Instagram
- Read Cap Puckhaber’s thoughts on X
- Join the conversation on Threads
- Follow Cap Puckhaber on Mastodon
- Browse my Pins on Pinterest
- See my Marketing Articles on Medium
- Follow Cap Puckhaber’s Company Page on LinkedIn
- Check out Cap Puckhaber on BlueSky
- Follow Cap Puckhaber on Substack


Cap Puckhaber
Backpacker, Marketer, Investor, Blogger, Husband, Dog-Dad, Golfer, Snowboarder
Cap Puckhaber is a marketing strategist, finance writer, and outdoor enthusiast from Reno, Nevada.
He writes across CapPuckhaber.com, TheHikingAdventures.com, SimpleFinanceBlog.com, and BlackDiamondMarketingSolutions.com.
Follow him for honest, real-world advice backed by 20+ years of experience.

