Junk Fees & Hidden Costs: Are Airline Companies Honest?
By Cap Puckhaber, MarketingSpiritual.com, Reno, Nevada
Updated: 11/3/26
Few industries test customer patience like airlines. A fare that looks cheap online grows once you add a bag, pick a seat or change your plans. Then a delay stretches into hours with little explanation. And the airline’s marketing promises a smooth, friendly journey that many travelers don’t recognize.
That gap makes airlines one of the best case studies in marketing ethics. In this post, I’ll look at how fees took over airline pricing and the fight over whether airlines must disclose them upfront. I’ll also cover what’s happening with refunds and delay rules, and what Southwest’s decision to end free bags shows about brand promises. The lessons apply to any business that sets prices or handles disappointed customers. I’ll also share the fee strategy I’d steer any client away from.
Why airlines make a useful case study
Airlines sit at an uncomfortable intersection of thin profit margins, complex pricing and high customer emotion. People fly for weddings, funerals, vacations and work. When something goes wrong, the stakes feel personal.
Airlines also compete heavily on price. Search engines and booking sites usually sort flights by fare, so the lowest advertised number often wins the click. That creates a strong incentive to make the base fare look as small as possible and recover revenue elsewhere.
Those same pressures exist in many industries. Hotels, ticket sellers, rental car companies, internet providers and food delivery apps all face them. Airlines just show the tension more clearly than most. Because almost everyone has flown, the examples are easy to recognize.
How fees took over airline pricing
The unbundling of the ticket
A plane ticket used to include most of the trip. Checked bags, seat selection, snacks and changes were usually part of the fare. Over time, airlines unbundled those pieces and began charging for them separately.
Unbundling isn’t automatically dishonest. Travelers who fly with only a backpack and don’t care where they sit can save money. Some people genuinely prefer paying only for what they use. For those travelers, unbundling is a real benefit.
The ethical problem comes from how the price is presented. When the advertised fare leaves out costs most travelers will pay, comparison shopping breaks down. The cheapest-looking flight may end up costing more than a competitor’s once everything is added. Travelers often discover that only after they’ve committed.
The money behind the fees
Fees became a huge business. CBS News reported on checked bag fee revenue at US airlines, citing Bureau of Transportation Statistics data. US airlines collected about $7.27 billion in checked bag fees in one year, up from $7.07 billion the year before. American, Delta and United each brought in more than $1 billion from checked bags alone.
Those numbers don’t include seat selection, change fees, priority boarding or other extras. They also explain why airlines fight hard to protect fee revenue. For many carriers, ancillary fees are a major part of the business model. So any change to how fees are shown touches a big source of income.
That’s not a moral judgment on its own. Businesses need revenue to operate safely. The question is whether customers can see the full cost clearly before they buy.
The fight over fee disclosure
What the rule would have required
The US Department of Transportation tried to address this with a fee disclosure rule. It would have required airlines to show upfront what they charge for a first and second checked bag, a carry-on and changing or canceling a ticket. The goal was to let travelers compare the real cost of flights before booking. Supporters saw it as a simple fix for a common frustration.
Major airlines and their trade group, Airlines for America, sued to block it. Upgraded Points reported that a federal appeals court threw out the airline fee disclosure rule in February 2026. The Fifth Circuit found that DOT had violated federal procedural law when it issued the rule, and it vacated the rule entirely.
As a result, airlines don’t currently have to change how they disclose extra fees. The article noted that DOT could try again in the future. So for now, fee transparency depends largely on each airline’s own choices.
The arguments on each side
Airlines argued the rule went beyond DOT’s legal authority. The trade group also said it would confuse consumers and complicate the buying process. It argued that airlines already disclose all fees before a ticket is purchased, so the rule addressed a problem that didn’t exist.
Supporters of the rule saw it differently. They argued that disclosing fees at checkout is too late, since travelers have already chosen a flight based on the base fare. Showing fees earlier, they said, would make comparison shopping fair.
Both sides have a point. Fees are usually disclosed somewhere before purchase. But a fee revealed late in the process gives travelers far less clarity than one shown while they’re still choosing. That distinction matters for any business, whatever the law requires.
Refunds, delays and what’s still required
Automatic refunds
One major passenger protection remains in place. A DOT rule that took effect in late 2024 requires airlines to issue automatic refunds when a flight is canceled or significantly changed and the passenger chooses not to travel. According to Consumers’ Checkbook, a significant change includes departure or arrival changes of more than three hours domestically or six hours internationally.
Refunds must go back to the original payment method, not as vouchers, unless the traveler chooses otherwise. They’re due within seven business days for credit card purchases. Travelers can also get bag fees refunded when checked bags are significantly delayed, and fees refunded for paid extras like Wi-Fi that weren’t provided. Before this rule, many travelers had to argue for refunds or settle for vouchers.
That rule shows how clear policies can reduce conflict. When travelers know exactly what they’re owed, there’s less room for frustrating arguments at the gate. Because the rules are simple, frontline staff have less to argue about too.
The withdrawn compensation rule
DOT had also proposed a rule that would have required airlines to compensate passengers for significant delays caused by the airline. The Points Guy reported that the Department of Transportation officially withdrew that proposal in November 2025. That withdrawal came after airlines lobbied to roll back several consumer protections.
Supporters of the withdrawal argued that competition between airlines, rather than new regulation, should drive better service. Airlines had pushed to roll back a range of consumer protections, saying they raised costs that would ultimately show up in fares. Consumer advocates countered that compensation rules give airlines a stronger reason to avoid disruptions and treat stranded travelers fairly.
Whatever you think of the policy, the result is the same for travelers. Compensation for delays now depends largely on each airline’s own policies, so reading those policies matters more. Airlines that publish generous, clear commitments can turn that into a real selling point.
What Southwest’s bag change shows about brand promises
The end of Bags Fly Free
For more than 50 years, Southwest let passengers check bags for free. “Bags Fly Free” grew into a core part of the brand, printed on napkins and featured in ads. NBC reported on Southwest ending its free checked bags policy under pressure from activist investor Elliott Investment Management.
Customers reacted strongly. One Southwest Instagram post drew more than 14,000 replies, far above its usual numbers. Some travelers said free bags were the main reason they chose Southwest. Southwest had previously estimated that charging for bags could cost it significant market share, though management later said customer booking behavior had changed.
Southwest’s stock rose after the announcement, while some rivals’ shares fell. Investors liked the revenue. Many loyal customers did not. That split shows how a decision can look smart on a spreadsheet and painful in customer conversations.
The lesson for any brand
Southwest had every right to change its pricing. Businesses adjust to costs, competition and investor pressure all the time. The lesson is about what happens when a business abandons a promise that defined its brand.
When a policy becomes part of your identity, customers treat it like a commitment. Changing it can feel like a broken promise, even when the reasons make financial sense. You can still change course. Just expect a loss of goodwill and explain the change honestly.
If you’re building a brand around a promise, choose one you can keep for the long haul. And when you have to change it, say so plainly, explain why and offer something real to the customers who relied on it. Since loyal customers feel the change most, they deserve the most care.
Spirit and the limits of the low base fare
Spirit Airlines took unbundling further than most, with very low base fares and fees for nearly everything else. I wrote about Spirit in my post on affordable luxury and marketing manipulation. The airline ceased operations in May 2026 after two bankruptcies.
Many factors caused Spirit’s collapse, including fuel costs and a blocked merger. But its story shows a risk for any business built mainly on a low headline price. When competitors matched that price, Spirit had little brand loyalty to rely on.
A low price can win a click. Trust is what wins the next booking. So any business competing mainly on price should ask what will keep customers once a rival matches it.
Loyalty programs and moving goalposts
Airline loyalty programs raise their own transparency questions. Many airlines now earn significant revenue from co-branded credit cards, and perks like free bags increasingly come through those cards. Southwest’s new bag policy, for example, gives a free checked bag to its co-branded cardholders.
Points and miles can also lose value over time. Airlines sometimes raise the number of miles needed for a reward or change how status is earned. When those changes happen with little notice, members feel the program moved the goalposts after they’d already invested.
Honest loyalty marketing gives members plenty of warning before changes and explains them clearly. It avoids promising “free” perks that really require an annual card fee. Because loyalty programs are built on trust, surprise devaluations hit especially hard.
What honest airline marketing looks like
Clear prices and honest communication
Honest airline marketing would start with pricing travelers can actually compare. Show the cost of a typical trip, including a bag and a seat, alongside the base fare. Make fee tables easy to find instead of burying them in help pages or long terms of service.
During disruptions, honesty matters even more. Travelers want timely updates through texts, email or the app, with a real explanation of what’s happening. “Operational issues” tells people nothing. “We’re waiting for a replacement crew, expected in 90 minutes” helps them plan.
When the cause is the airline’s own problem, like a staffing shortage or mechanical issue, say so. People handle bad news better than vague excuses. Because honesty lowers frustration, it also makes the gate agent’s job easier.
Be clear about basic economy
Basic economy fares are a good example of where clarity matters. These fares often come with restrictions, like no seat selection, no changes or last boarding. Some travelers choose them knowingly to save money, which is perfectly fine.
Problems start when travelers don’t realize what they gave up until they’re at the airport. Honest marketing shows the restrictions right next to the price, in plain words. A simple side-by-side comparison of fare types lets people choose with their eyes open. Since many travelers book quickly on their phones, those details need to be impossible to miss.
Empathy and extra care
Airline staff deal with stressed, tired travelers every day. A sincere apology and a clear offer of help can turn a bad experience into a tolerable one. Meal vouchers, rebooking assistance and waived fees during long delays all show that the airline takes responsibility.
Some travelers need extra support. Families with young children, older adults and people with disabilities may need help with boarding, connections or rebooking. Airlines that plan for them in advance show care that marketing alone can’t fake. Those moments are often what travelers remember and share long after the trip.
The fee strategy I’d steer any client away from
Here’s the “don’t” I’d underline. Don’t build your profits on fees customers resent and didn’t see coming. A fee that surprises customers at checkout may raise revenue this quarter. It also teaches them to distrust your advertised prices from then on.
I’ve seen this pattern outside airlines too, including with small businesses. Service businesses add “convenience” fees, booking platforms add “service” charges and subscription companies add fees after a free trial. Each one may be technically disclosed. Customers still feel tricked when the final number doesn’t match what they expected.
If a fee is mandatory, include it in the price. But if an extra is optional, make it easy to see and easy to skip. Customers can respect a higher honest price far more than a low price that keeps growing. They may not always choose you, but they’ll trust you when they do.
What lift tickets taught me about pricing
Snowboarders have watched lift ticket prices change a lot. Many resorts now use dynamic pricing, where the cost changes with the date and how far ahead you buy. A ticket can cost very different amounts depending on when you book.
The resorts I trust most show those prices clearly on a calendar. I can see exactly what each day costs and decide whether to buy early or go another day. The price varies, but nothing is hidden.
That’s the difference between complex pricing and deceptive pricing. Prices can change with demand and still be honest, as long as customers can see the real number before they commit. Since I can see the full calendar, I don’t feel tricked even when I pay more.
How other industries handle the same problem
Airlines aren’t the only industry wrestling with fees. Hotels have long added resort fees, ticket sellers add service charges and food delivery apps add delivery and service fees on top of menu prices. Each one makes the advertised price look lower than what customers actually pay.
Regulators have pushed back in some of these areas. The FTC now requires sellers of live-event tickets and short-term lodging to show the total price upfront, including mandatory fees. That rule doesn’t cover airlines, which fall under DOT, but it shows where expectations are heading.
Some businesses have chosen all-in pricing on their own. They show one number that includes everything, and they use that simplicity in their marketing. Because customers are tired of surprise charges, a clear total can become a real competitive advantage.
Lessons for every business
You don’t need to run an airline to learn from one. Start by looking at your own pricing from a customer’s point of view, ideally on a phone, since that’s how many people buy. Does the price you advertise match what most customers actually pay? If not, close that gap.
Next, look at how you handle disruptions. When an order is late or a service falls through, do customers get a clear explanation and a fair remedy? Write down your policy, and make sure every employee knows it. When staff can offer a fair remedy without asking permission, problems end faster.
Then think about the promises built into your brand. Whatever customers believe you stand for, protect it. If you ever need to change it, be honest about why and treat loyal customers with respect.
Why honesty is good business for airlines
Some airlines argue that hiding fees until later is simply how the market works. If everyone else advertises a low base fare, the honest airline looks expensive in search results. That pressure is real, and it’s why regulators keep revisiting the issue.
Still, there’s a business case for honesty. Travelers remember which airlines treated them fairly during a canceled trip or a lost bag. They also remember which ones surprised them with fees. Over time, that memory shapes where they book, especially for travelers who fly often.
Clear pricing can also reduce an airline’s costs. Fewer surprised customers means fewer complaints, fewer chargebacks and less time spent at service desks. Because those costs rarely show up in fee revenue reports, they’re easy to overlook.
What a fair delay policy looks like
Since federal delay compensation is off the table for now, airlines have room to stand out with their own policies. A fair policy states clearly what travelers get when the airline causes a long delay. That might include meal vouchers after a set number of hours, hotel rooms for overnight delays and free rebooking on the next available flight.
The best policies are easy to find and easy to use. Travelers shouldn’t have to argue at a gate to get what was promised. Automatic vouchers sent through the app, for example, remove friction for everyone.
Any business can borrow this idea. Write down what customers get when you fall short, publish it and honor it without making people fight for it. Customers who see you keep that promise once will trust you far more the next time something goes wrong.
Tips for travelers
Travelers can protect themselves with a few habits. Compare the total cost of a trip, including bags and seats, rather than the base fare alone. Read the airline’s policies on delays, cancellations and refunds before you book, especially for important trips.
If your flight is canceled or significantly changed and you choose not to travel, you’re entitled to a refund to your original payment method. Ask for it clearly, and keep records of everything, including screenshots of delay notices. For delays and other problems, check the airline’s own customer commitments, since those now determine much of what you’re owed.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are airline junk fees?
Junk fees usually refer to extra charges added on top of an advertised fare, like checked bag, carry-on, seat selection and change fees. They can make the final price much higher than the base fare. US airlines collected about $7.27 billion in checked bag fees in one year, according to Bureau of Transportation Statistics data reported by CBS News.
Do airlines have to show fees upfront?
Not under the DOT fee disclosure rule, which a federal appeals court threw out in February 2026. Airlines say they already disclose fees before purchase. DOT could try a new rule in the future.
Are airlines required to give refunds for canceled flights?
Yes, under a DOT rule that took effect in late 2024. Airlines must automatically refund passengers whose flights are canceled or significantly changed if they choose not to travel. Refunds go back to the original payment method unless the traveler chooses a voucher.
Do airlines have to pay compensation for delays?
A proposed federal rule requiring delay compensation was withdrawn in November 2025. Compensation now depends mostly on each airline’s own policies. Check those policies before you book.
Why did Southwest start charging for bags?
Southwest ended its long-running Bags Fly Free policy under pressure from activist investor Elliott Investment Management to raise profits. The change drew strong customer backlash. Southwest expected the fees to add significant revenue.
What can other businesses learn from airline marketing?
Show prices customers can compare honestly, explain problems clearly and protect the promises that define your brand. Hidden or surprising fees erode trust. Clear policies reduce conflict when things go wrong.
Check out Grubhub’s $25M Settlement: A Case Study in Deceptive Marketing
Read EU Consumer Protection: A New Stand Against Deceptive Online Sellers
Check out Top 10 Deceptive Marketing Scams to Avoid
More Blogs from Cap Puckhaber

Follow Cap Puckhaber on Social Media
- Connect with Cap Puckhaber on Facebook
- See Cap Puckhaber’s latest adventures on Instagram
- Read Cap Puckhaber’s thoughts on X
- Join the conversation on Threads
- Follow Cap Puckhaber on Mastodon
- Browse my Pins on Pinterest
- See my Marketing Articles on Medium
- Follow Cap Puckhaber’s Company Page on LinkedIn
- Check out Cap Puckhaber on BlueSky
- Follow Cap Puckhaber on Substack


Cap Puckhaber
Backpacker, Marketer, Investor, Blogger, Husband, Dog-Dad, Golfer, Snowboarder
Cap Puckhaber is a marketing strategist, finance writer, and outdoor enthusiast from Reno, Nevada.
He writes across CapPuckhaber.com, TheHikingAdventures.com, SimpleFinanceBlog.com, and BlackDiamondMarketingSolutions.com.
Follow him for honest, real-world advice backed by 20+ years of experience.

